Answer: The Evidence for the Truth of Islam:
The answer to this question can be explained from two perspectives:
- From an internal perspective, using Islamic teachings.
- From an external perspective, independent of Islamic teachings.
A) Internal Perspective
From within the framework of Islamic teachings, a Muslim believes that Islam is superior to other religions. This is because Islamic doctrine holds that belief in all previous prophets is a fundamental part of the faith, yet the most complete and preferred religion is Islam. The Qur'an states:
"Whoever seeks a religion other than Islam, it will never be accepted of him, and in the Hereafter, he will be among the losers" (3:85).
From this perspective, Islam is seen as the culmination of the teachings of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, and Jesus (peace be upon them all). It is the fully perfected religion, as expressed in the Qur'an:
"Today I have perfected your religion for you, completed My favour upon you, and have chosen Islam as your way of life" (5:3).
This finality and completeness make Islam the most divine and pleasing religion to Allah. Consequently, the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is described as the Seal of the Prophets, the pinnacle of all messengers. The Qur'anic verses highlight the superiority of both the Prophet and his teachings over previous messengers and their respective scriptures.
Islam views all prophets as part of a unified mission, with the final messenger bringing the most complete and comprehensive message. Since divine religions progressively aimed for human perfection, the later religions are necessarily more complete than their predecessors. For this reason, Islam, being the last and most perfected religion, must be followed.
B) External Perspective
From an external perspective, evidence for the truth of Islam cannot rely on Qur'anic verses or Islamic traditions, as non-Muslims do not accept these as proof. Instead, the truth of Islam must first be established through rational and empirical means.
To determine the truth of Islam, various approaches can be used, such as analysing the unique features of Islamic teachings in epistemology, worldview, anthropology, and moral and ethical systems. For instance, Martyr Ayatollah Murtaza Mutahhari highlights several distinctive characteristics of Islam:
- Epistemology:
- Humans are capable of understanding the truths of the universe.
- Knowledge can be acquired through nature (observable signs), the self (inner signs), history (social experiences), and reason.
- Tools for acquiring knowledge include the senses, reasoning, purification of the soul, and studying others’ scientific achievements.
- Worldview and Anthropology:
- The universe is a creation of God, and all of reality belongs to Him.
- The material world reflects a lower degree of a higher, unseen reality.
- Human existence has a dual purpose: beginning with God and returning to Him.
- Humanity is equal in creation, and virtue is based on knowledge, piety, and striving.
- Ideology:
- Islam presents a comprehensive, dynamic, and practical ideology that balances individual rights and social responsibilities.
- It respects individual freedoms while promoting social justice.
By comparing these attributes with those of other religions and philosophies, one can see the unique and superior aspects of Islam. For instance:
- Other religions often fail to present a balanced view of worldly and spiritual life, while Islam provides guidance for both.
- Many religions have been subject to distortion, unlike the Qur'an, which has been preserved in its original form.
- Islam addresses all aspects of human life—individual, social, ethical, and political—in a holistic manner.
The Source of a Divine Religion
To determine whether a religion is divine, one must examine the prophet who brought it. Evidence for the prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him) is traditionally established through:
- Miracles:
- The Qur'an is considered the eternal miracle of the Prophet due to its unmatched eloquence, profound knowledge, and lack of contradictions.
- Other miracles include the splitting of the moon and the Night Journey (Mi'raj).
- Predictions by Previous Prophets:
- Previous scriptures, such as the Torah and the Bible, contain references to the coming of a final prophet, such as the mention of "Paraclete" in Christian texts, interpreted by Muslims as referring to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
- Historical Evidence and Circumstances:
- The Prophet’s unparalleled moral character, even before his prophethood, earned him the title of "Al-Amin" (The Trustworthy).
- His profound teachings emerged from a context of ignorance, demonstrating that his message could not have been self-generated.
- The transformative impact of Islam on its followers and society further attests to the divine origin of his mission.
In Summary:
From both internal and external perspectives, the truth of Islam is supported by rational, historical, and spiritual evidence. Its comprehensive teachings, preserved scripture, and the unmatched character and achievements of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) collectively affirm its divine origin.